So I'd like to talk to you about the worst comic book character currently in publication.
No, it's not
Squirrel Girl or any of the other GLI folks. It's not even
Fasaud, who inexplicably popped up relatively recently in Union Jack #2.
It's this guy.

What was that? That was the sound of a million nerds gasping. Hating Wolverine is heresy, a veritable thought-crime against Marvel herself. Even as we speak, hundreds of sweaty guys are taking their replica display Wolverine claws off the wall and tearing furtively at their
wolf tee-shirts.
Hate Wolverine? How could you! Well, easier than you'd think. Let me put it this way: Wolverine makes Superman look like an engrossing character.
Uh oh, now I've dragged Superman into this. Big Blue can have a free pass, for reasons best saved for another day, but even the most ardent Superman fan will admit that he can occasionally get a little tired. Well, Wolverine's about a hundred times more tired than Superman will ever be.
My problem with Wolverine is as follows:
Wolverine is an uninteresting, bland character who exists solely to sell issues of comic books and do 'awesome' stuff.
Wolverine exists to exemplify the worst things about comic books. Let's discuss why.
What powers does Wolverine have? Well, he's invulnerable. His healing power has been written, retconned and rerolled to the point of ridiculousness. A few years ago there was a Wolverine story arc in which he was destroyed down to a single scrap of skin (literally, just a flap of skin), which he then regenerated from and came back to keep fighting. The idea that any force in the galaxy poses a threat to him is unlikely at best and ridiculous at worst. According to continuity, if even a tiny fragment of Wolverine were to exist in any way, he could regenerate to full health. Why are we even pretending that he's not completely invincible? Sure, he can get knocked down, and some writers have made it so he takes some time to recover to full health. Where's the thrill in that? No matter how grim circumstances get, Wolverine will always, ALWAYS heal back up. There's no mystery, no tension and no suspense.
Add on to this that he has quite possibly one of the most ridiculous powers written, namely, the claws in his hands. Leave your computer, go to your kitchen and take three butter knives out of the drawer. Now get some tape and tape them to the back of your hands. Taa daa, you're Wolverine! Now work on being immortal.
Fact of the matter is, Wolverine stabs stuff. He gets hurt. He stabs stuff some more. He gets hurt. He slices stuff, something dies, he heals all the way and smokes a cigarette or something. He's a one trick pony at best.
Compounding this is the most uninteresting writing ever done for a comic book character. For as long as I can remember, Wolverine has been the character that writers throw stuff at for the expressed purpose of seeing what sticks. But they don't throw just any old stuff, no. They only throw the most XTREEEEME stuff at Wolverine. The kids these days are into moody western gunslingers? Oh shoot, Wolverine's like a
gritty cowboy type! Japan and ninjas and stuff are totally in? Didn't you know that Wolverine was such a brave warrior that
samurais invited him to train with them and stuff! History buff? Betcha didn't know
Wolverine was in WW2!
And in WW1! Continuity's got you all bogged down? Well, due to some emotional trauma and stuff, Wolverine gets amnesia and doesn't remember his gritty and dark past! Off hand, I count the number of times Wolverine has gotten amnesia at like six or seven. But that's OK, it just allows writers to write more AWESOME stuff without any encumbrances like history until it's convenient to bring it back.
(The superhero equivalent of a MySpace picture)
To top it off, the 'do whatever is cool' doesn't stop at his history. It's all about his character. Cyclops is the leader of the X-Men? Wolverine hates him because Wolverine doesn't do authority. Take THAT, mom and dad! Someone needs Wolverine's help? Sorry, but he's a lone wolf who plays by his own rules. Forget the twelve (on average) comic book covers he's on every month. He's too busy brooding alone, or drinking beer and playing poker, or hitting on women. When Hugh Jackman flipped someone off in the X-Men movie using Wolverine's claws, fans cheered as it was a 'total Wolverine thing to do'. Yeah man, SCREW YOU! He, like, has sideburns! And flips people off! He's like The Fonz, but with today's hip youth sensibility!
It's as if
Rob Liefeld's drawings became a life mantra (although at least Liefeld gave us Deadpool). Wolverine is calculated to be the most gruff, anti-authority, 'tough but sensitive troubled loner with a past' that could ever exist. Even when he's written well, he's still the 'tough guy' who does what he wants. He's like Axl Rose, still playing the same songs to the same group of fans who won't admit that the whole thing's a little stale.
Worst of all, he's held up as the figurehead of why comics are cool. He's what nerds imagine the cool kids are like when nobody's around, pumped up to the power of ten. He's an awful, totally two-dimensional character with very few redeeming qualities, but he's still held up as why comics are awesome. Alongside
this guy, he's Marvel's #1 money maker, so he probably won't go anywhere any time soon. But please, future writers of America, do SOMETHING, ANYTHING, to make Wolverine fresh. Give him a sex change, make him sustain a head injury that makes him a cheerful optimist, do SOMETHING!
Until then, scores of better heroes will play second fiddle to Wolverine. Just as well; as long as they're behind him in line they won't get hit when he does a triple backflip off his motorcycle while on fire and listening to the rock music.
|