1
Various Thoughts on 'Alan Wake'
Posted by Austin
on
11:02 PM
in
video games
A couple days ago, I was lucky enough to stumble into a gift certificate. Now that I have Netflix, I don't buy too many new movies, so I thought instead I'd video game it up and play some stuff that I had wanted, but never had the drive, to buy and play before. 'Alan Wake' was at the top of that list.
Let's talk about something else for a moment. Let's pretend that you're in High School and single. You've been single for a while, and have almost given up on finding someone. Sure, there have been a few people who you've felt pretty close to, but nobody who is just PERFECT for you. One day you're eating lunch, and a beautiful girl shows up out of nowhere. She just enrolled in school, and lucky for you, she's available to hang out right now! You start to talk to each other, and you find out you love all the same things. You loved 'Twin Peaks'? I loved 'Twin Peaks'! You think Stephen King is pretty great? Yeah, me too, I don't get all the crap dumped on him! We're both fans of horror movies, and action movies, and we love suspense and mysteries and the supernatural and you're totally available?! It's love!
So you start seeing this girl a lot. The first night you hang out, she comes over to your place, and she says, 'Hey, I thought tonight we could stay in, order some pizza and watch 'Twin Peaks'!' This will be awesome, you think to yourself, so you guys do, and you have an absolute blast. Cue the next night, and she's over at your place again, and she has a pizza, and she wants to watch 'Twin Peaks'. That's cool, love that show. You work your way through the series each successive night, and each night, she brings pizza, and you guys just sorta hang out. You make it through the entire show, and the next night... she's at your door, and she's got pizza, and she wants to watch the first episode again.
'Hey, I know, let's go out', you'll say, but it falls on deaf ears. She really wants to watch 'Twin Peaks' and you simply can't talk her out of it.All of a sudden, some of the shine is gone, and what's left is this confusing pile of mixed emotions, where you know you're supposed to love something, but there's just one boring, repetitive thing holding you back. You've watched 'Twin Peaks' about five times all the way through. You're pretty sure that's enough.
This is 'Alan Wake' in a nutshell. It's got everything I should love, and I do love it. We both share a passion for 'Twin Peaks' (AW is absolutely shameless about stealing from the show), and I'm absolutely riveted by the plot. But the gameplay is repetitive.
Want to know how to play 'Alan Wake'? Do the interesting stuff, and explore for a little bit. Oh crap, now it's nighttime... hold down the left trigger, now press the right trigger twice. Do that again. And again. Yay, now move to the next area. Do it again. And again. And again. Hey, it's a new level! Let's explore some more, and now I took away all your items, and you're back to having no ammo. Start holding down the left trigger...
I mean, don't get me wrong, the experience is fantastic. Skulking through dark forests being absolutely terrified is great. The problem is, combat is ultra-repetitive. Ammo isn't scarce enough that it's really survival horror... and it's not action-y enough that it's a shooter. It's a survival horror game where you have to monotonously chug through enemies now and again to see some really pretty visuals and follow a really interesting story.
Honestly, the game is inspired. I especially love the 'Twilight Zone' knockoff TV show you can watch a couple times throughout the game. There are problems, however, that take the game from being absolutely perfect, to being pretty OK. The controls feel clumsy at times (something I attribute to Alan Wake himself, which causes me to frequently go 'OH ALAN, WHY DID YOU WALK OFF THAT CLIFF?'). The combat is boring after the first 100 guys you kill. And some of the enemies that start to appear mid-game are just obnoxious (highlight to read: The possessed poltergeist inanimate objects... they are awful. That first section under the train tracks on the bridge, where you have to fight like ten of them at once? Ugh.).
Overall I wouldn't caution anyone against playing 'Alan Wake'; on the contrary, I'd even recommend it. Just with a caveat, that you'll probably find the combat boring, and end up wondering, 'Why can't I just skip to the story parts?'


















